KS keyboard was designed to use it on the English teletypewriter
machine in 1969 by the South Korean Government. However, Korean
government adopted it as a standard keyboard for computer
in 1982.
Following defects are found with the KS keyboard and APH
keyboard has removed all of these defects of KS keyboard.
1. Difficult to memorize positions of each key: Though, it
has separation of consonants (located on the left hand side)
and vowels (on the right hand side), it did not follow the
scientific logics of Hangul. Remedy by APHK: Not only it separated
consonants (on left) from vowels (on right), but also arranged
by sequence of location of organs where the sound created,
but also clustered together by similar sound values and shapes
of alphabets, so that one can easily remember the location
of keys.
2. Input speed is very slow in comparison to other keyboard
arrays: It is slower than Gong, Byung Woo keyboard (about
20%). It is much slower than APH keyboard (minimum of 50%
in serial input, and a few hundred % slower than simultaneous
input system). Remedy by APHK keyboard: Arranged by careful
study of Hangul frequencies. More frequently used ones on
home rows and inside ones. More usage of thumbs for the bottom
row.
3. Visual confusion by frequent movement of trailing consonants
and initial consonants by up and down movements: As the computer
can not determine whether the consonants can be used as the
initial consonants or the trailing consonants until the following
keys are inputted. If the following alphabet is a vowel, it
moves to the next position to become an initial consonant,
otherwise, it will stay as a trailing consonant. Remedy by
APHK: It has separated initial consonants and trailing consonants
on the keyboard itself.
4. Unnecessary internal re-programming to assemble for a syllabic
character: KS keyboard can only input Hangul alphabet serially
as in English input, and Korean Hangul have to output assembled
syllabic character, it is necessary to assemble it internally
with Hangul automata to find the appropriate code number for
assembled (or semi-assembled) character to output. Remedy
by APHK: In the input stage, APHK system pushes keys of assembled
syllabic character simultaneously, and output character is
painted by its shape according to the given rules.
5. Too many unnecessary character codes: Currently there are
12,106 code points(11,172 codes for Hangul Syllables, 240
for Hangul Jamo and 94 for Compatible Hangul Jamo) are assigned
to Hangul in ISO/IEC 60646, which is the second largest code
points after Chinese Hanzi. Remedy by APHK: Assigning only
45 Jamo (17 Initial consonant Jamo, 11 Median Jamo and 17
Trailing consonant Jamo), treating all other Jamo as glyphs,
it can create millions of syllabic characters. Only what it
requires is development of the algorism how to place these
different glyphs within given spaces.
6. It cannot process any Korean documents produced before
1933, and cannot process foreign languages, due to the elimination
of four archaic Hangul Jamo from keyboard: namely, Pan-siot,
Yet-ieung, Yeorin-hieut and Are-A. KS keyboard doesn’t have
these four alphabets. Remedy by APHK: It has all four old
Hangul alphabets, assigned on the top of similar looking and
sounded alphabets, accessible by shift keys. Pan-siot on the
top of ㅅ, Yet-ieung on the top of ㅇ, Yeorin-hieut on the top
of ㅎ, and Are-A on the top of ㅏ.
7. Excessive use of left hand: KS keyboard has consonants
on the left hand and vowels on the right hand. Korean Hangul
syllabic character is consisted of either consonant(s) and
vowel(s), or initial consonant(s), vowel(s) and trailing consonant(s).
In the case of later, left hand fingers have to use more than
right hand fingers. The ratio between left hand finger usage
and right hand usage is 56.82:42.18, which means left hand
use 34.7% more than right hand. Most of ordinary people are
right handed and using left hand fingers excessively causes
more frequent fatigue on left hand and main reason of carpal
tunnel syndrome on that hand. APHK keyboard has assigned on
both hands evenly.
8. Confusion of one vowel(ㅠ) located on the right hand side:
KS keyboard has consonants on the left hand side and vowels
on the right. There is one exception. Vowel ㅠ is located on
the right hand side. This causes not only visual confusion,
but also our autonomous nerve system confuses between vowels
and consonants. Also it creates confusions on the ergonomically
designed keyboard which usually separates right and left hand
apart. Those who do not know much about the Korean Hangul
misunderstand this ㅠ vowel as a consonants. APH keyboard removed
such confusion by completely separating initial consonants,
vowels and trailing consonants and assigned completely on
different locations.
9. Benign neglect of phonetic value of Korean Hangul. When
Hangul was proclaimed as Hoonmin Jungeum (Teaching of People
with Correct Sound - an original name of Hangul) in 1446 by
King Sejong, he said, where there are natural sounds (phonetics)
in nature, there should be writing system which is equivalent
to it. Therefore, Hangul is invented to scribe all the sounds
in the nature, including all the phonetics of languages. However,
KS keyboard is a hindrance to this proclamation. APH keyboard
has removed all of these hindrances by making it a more flexible
to create more than several million phonetic syllabifies
10. KS keyboard can not input simultaneously, though it was
invented over 5 centuries ago to write syllabic characters
and perfectly good writing system for modern computers for
simultaneous input. The reason why it can not input simultaneously
is that it mimics English system, which has to depend on other
system such as shorthand machine to input alphabets for fast
simultaneous input. Remedy by APH keyboard is that it has
separate initial consonants and trailing consonants, so that
it can type simultaneously as in the case of stenographic
shorthand machine.
11. Same finger use: As KS keyboard does not have trailing
consonants separate from the initial consonants, it has to
type with too many same fingers. For example to type 학교, with
KS system, you have to type ㅎ ㅏ ㄱ ㄱ ㅛ, which requires to strike
ㄱ twice. There are too many such words which require same
finger use consecutively. APH keyboard doesn’t have such consecutive
same finger use, as it has separate trailing consonants.
12. Too many shift keys use. Since KS keyboard input is only
serial input of Hangul Jamo, just like English input system,
some words have double and triple meanings without separation
of syllable ending. For instance, one type ㅇ ㅏ ㄱ ㄱ ㅣ ㄷ ㅏ,
it could mean 악기다, which means ‘this is a musical instrument,
or 아끼다, which means ‘one is sparing’, or ‘one is try to save’.
Therefore, to separate the syllable ending KS keyboard need
five double consonants (ㄲ,ㄸ,ㅆ,ㅉ,ㅃ), placed on the top of each
respective single consonants. These five consonants and two
vowels are used with shift keys and their usage is 2.09% of
the total. Since shift key is used with small fingers and
requires some time to move there, typing is three times slower
than without it. Since the typing rhythm is broken, it is
prone to the miss-typing. APH keyboard do not have anything
like it, except the archaic Jamo, on the upper level.
13. Impossible to input foreign language with KS keyboard.
Korean language belongs to Ural Altaic language group, and
therefore, other languages are not easy to spell with KS keyboard.
Due to the fact that there are no archaic Jamo and not possible
to mix Jamos freely to create certain non-Korean sound. It
can not apply to other languages. APH keyboard is designed
to mix them freely, including with archaic Hangul Jamo.
|